Mermaids and Bird Wives

Read

Two stories – One from Scotland and one from Japan

Note: A Selkie (or Silkie) is not quite a mermaid, but a seal-human creature that is found throughout Celtic and Norse stories. In places surrounded by water, sea-based people were a rich source for use in stories.

The Silkie Wife

Those in the Shetland and Orkney Islands who know no better, are persuaded that the seals, or silkies, as they call them, can doff their coverings at times, and disport themselves as men and women.

A fisher once turning a ridge of rock, discovered a beautiful bit of green turf adjoining the shingle, sheltered by rocks on the landward side, and over this turf and shingle two beautiful women chasing each other. Just at the man’s feet lay two sealskins, one of which he took up to examine it. The women, catching sight of him, screamed out, and ran to get possession of the skins. One seized the article on the ground, donned it in a thrice, and plunged into the sea; the other wrung her hands, cried, and begged the fisher to restore her property; but he wanted a wife, and would not throw away the chance. He wooed her so earnestly and lovingly, that she put on some woman’s clothing which he brought her from his cottage, followed him home, and became his wife.

Some years later, when their home was enlivened by the presence of two children, the husband, awakening one night, heard voices in conversation from the kitchen. Stealing softly to the room door, he heard his wife talking in a low tone with someone outside the window. The interview was just at an end, and he had only time to ensconce himself in bed, when his wife was stealing across the room. He was greatly disturbed, but determined to do or say nothing till he should acquire further knowledge.

Next evening, as he was returning home by the strand, he spied a male and female seal sprawling on a rock a few yards out at sea.

The rougher animal, raising himself on his tail and fins, thus addressed the astonished man in the dialect spoken in these islands, “You deprived me of her whom I was to make my companion; and it was only yesternight that I discovered her outer garment, the loss of which obliged her to be your wife. I bear no malice, as you were kind to her in your own fashion; besides, my heart is too full of joy to hold any malice. Look on your wife for the last time.”

The other seal glanced at him with all the shyness and sorrow she could force into her now uncouth features; but when the bereaved husband rushed toward the rock to secure his lost treasure, she and her companion were in the water on the other side of it in a moment, and the poor fisherman was obliged to return sadly to his motherless children and desolate home.

Source: Legendary Fictions of the Irish Celts, collected and narrated by Patrick Kennedy (London: Macmillan and Company, 1866), pp. 122-24.

photograph of a statue of a woman holding what looks like a skin with a marine tale, behind is the ocean and rising above in the fog is a cliff
The statue of the selkie in Mikladalur, Faroe Islands

The Feathery Robe

On the coast of Suruga, at Miwo, there once lived a fisherman by the name of Hakurioo. One day when he was resting from his work on the bank in the sunshine he saw a brightly glistening white robe lying before him, delicate and translucent and entirely woven from feathers. At the place where the shoulders would fit on the wonderful robe there hung two wings.

He eagerly picked it up, wanting to take it home and carefully put it away, when a beautiful girl appeared before him. She sobbed aloud and demanded the return of her robe.

Hakurioo was at first not at all willing to give up his find. But then the girl said, amidst endless sobs and tears, that she was a heavenly goddess, and that she would have to remain miserably on earth as long as she did not have her feathery robe, that she had taken off while bathing, and which had thus wrongly come into his hands.

Moved by compassion, the fisherman said, “Very well, I will give your robe back to you, if in return you will dance the heavenly dance for me with which you daughters of heaven soar through the clouds.”

The maiden replied, “Yes, give me my robe, and you shall behold the most beautiful dance that I am able to dance.”

The fisherman considered for a moment and said, “No, dance first, and then I will give you your robe.”

watercolor, a man holds an elaborate robe of feathers while a woman kneels in the sand before him. The ocean and Mt. Fuji are behind them

With this the heavenly maiden grew angry and said, “Shame on you, that you doubt the words of a goddess! Quickly, give me my robe, for without it I am not able to dance. You will not regret it. That I promise you!”

Thereupon Hakurioo handed her the feathery robe. She immediately put it on and rose into the air. True to her words, before the fisherman’s amazed eyes she performed the most magnificent dance that one can imagine, at the same time singing the most beautiful, sensuous melodies, until Hakurioo did not know what was happening to him. In more and more beautiful loops she rose higher and higher, but it was a long time before she disappeared from the enchanted fisherman’s view, soaring into a light cloud that was drifting toward Fujiyama’s summit, with the last sounds of her godly song sounding in his ears.

Source: David Brauns, Japanische Märchen und Sagen (Leipzig: Verlag von Wilhelm Friedrich, 1885), pp. 349-50. Translated from the German by D. L. Ashliman. © 2008.

Can you think of a reason why stories that share certain types of plots might be present in very different parts of the globe?

Comments

20 responses to “Mermaid and Bird Wives”

  1. Naurah Romulus Avatar
    Naurah Romulus

    These stories have similar plots because they deal with universal themes that people everywhere can relate to. Themes like love, freedom, and control over one’s own life are experiences that people from all cultures understand.

  2. Anthea longville Avatar
    Anthea longville

    Reasons why stories that share certain types of plots might be present in very different parts of the globe is because most people across the globe share the same human experiences such as loss, love, pain, despair etc. Also the spreading of stories, myths and fables from one culture to another.

    1. Ariana Loyfman Avatar
      Ariana Loyfman

      I agree with your point. Regardless of where in the world you live, humans experience common emotions and experiences like love, pain, loss, happiness etc. So no matter where a story originated from, others around the world can find aspects of the story to relate to in one way or another.

  3. Mahnoor Avatar
    Mahnoor

    Stories that share the same plot may be present in different parts of the world because they share a universal message that everyone can relate to. In the stories above, the themes of love and freedom are present, which are emotions that all humans feel. These stories have moved around the world as people shifted and changed to fit into specific cultures, yet they all have the same goal of storytelling for society. 

    1. Shiraz Biggie Avatar
      Shiraz Biggie

      Folklorists who have tracked the movement of stories have added to our understanding of how ancient people migrated and came into contact with one another.

  4. Nitzan Naim Avatar
    Nitzan Naim

    Again, I agree with my peers: these themes reflect broader societal dynamics, such as gender roles, which are a universal social experience. One thing to add is that these themes not only cross cultures but also span across time, as they remain relevant even today.

    1. Shiraz Biggie Avatar
      Shiraz Biggie

      Yes! Do you think if someone were writing a version of this fairy tale today that they might change some of the story elements? What might that looks like?

  5. Anifat Abumislimova Avatar
    Anifat Abumislimova

    These stories share certain types of plots because they have similar experiences. Despite the fact that they are from different cultures, these stories teach us emotions and feelings such as love, pain, loss that all people have.

  6. Sofia Buttaro Avatar
    Sofia Buttaro

    Stories that share certain types of plots might be present in very different parts of the globe. Both tales, which are prevalent in many cultures around the world, have a similar storyline about a supernatural or magical person (often a woman) who loses her magical ability or independence when a man takes her garment, marries her, and then suffers consequences when she regains her power. Because they address issues of freedom, power, and desire that are universal, they may be found all across the world. Historical patterns of migration, trade, and cultural interaction have made them easier. These stories, despite their geographical variations, touch on real human issues.

    1. Amy Khait Avatar
      Amy Khait

      I agree with you on the fact that despite where these stories are in the world, they touch on issues that are universal.

  7. Alexa Mendez Avatar
    Alexa Mendez

    stories share certain types of plots around the world because everyone can relate to the issues being discussed such as love, despair and pain. These stories teach us about these issues and spread more awareness to human emotions.

  8. Brittany Giler Avatar
    Brittany Giler

    Folktales from different parts of the globe can share similar themes and plot elements, these shared elements highlight the universal nature of storytelling and the ways in which cultures can connect and influence one another. Stories often explore universal human experiences, such as love, loss, and the desire for connection. These themes transcend cultural boundaries and can be found in folktales from various regions to get the message across.

    1. Michelle Cortes Rodriguez Avatar
      Michelle Cortes Rodriguez

      I agree they share similar themes and plot elements.

  9. Selina Chen Avatar
    Selina Chen

    Both these folktales appear globally due to their similar universal themes of transformation and identity, resonating with shared human experiences across different cultures.

  10. Amy Khait Avatar
    Amy Khait

    I believe that these folktales are present throughout the world because no matter where a person comes from, there are certain things that are universal such as, the plots and themes. Also, emotions that are felt by all humans such as, love, desiring freedom and more. These are some of the things that are understood by cultures worldwide.

  11. Tory Sen Avatar
    Tory Sen

    People learn moral lessons from fairytales about contentment, striving, and greed. They also tell people to do what’s right for the group and follow God’s way, which makes people more thankful and stable in society.

  12. Victoria Lucenti Avatar
    Victoria Lucenti

    Stories that share similar types of plots might be present in very different parts of the globe because of the universal experience any person could relate to. These stories portray many messages, from moral lessons, to cultural experiences and lessons, life experiences, and societal experiences that can include the upper and lower class, economical relations that factor in wealth and power, and so much more that is not limited to this. However, these kinds of messages factor in how it is seen as a universal experience that many can relate to, as these factors are not restricted to one kind of society of readers, such as those living in New York, as a reader in Germany or England for example can still relate and connect to these kinds of stories because it is universal.

  13. VANESSA Avatar
    VANESSA

    We are all human. One thing we have in common is that we’ve experienced love, loss, pain, happiness in one way or another. We can all relate to these emotions. I think stories share certain types of plots in different parts of the globe because no matter where they are shared, we can all understand them and relate to them. Usually most stories have a plot in which we have all experienced and can relate to. Whether it’s about love, betrayal, pain, or happiness.

  14. Kaylee Pontone Avatar
    Kaylee Pontone

    No matter where someone is from, we all are human and experience the joys/sorrows of life. Stories work everywhere because anyone can relate to overcoming challenges, or failing in the face of them.

  15. Jaylyn Calles Avatar
    Jaylyn Calles

    The reason why stories that share certain types of plots might be present in very different parts of the globe is because they are relatable and can connect to themselves such as love, loss, freedom.

Leave a Reply to Anthea longville Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *