Thinking about Illustration

Often, we remember the illustrations in our childhood books sometimes more than we do the story. Here, you’ll learn a bit about the history of children’s illustrations and how we go about ‘reading’ them.

Alice was beginning to get very tired of sitting by her sister on the bank, and of having nothing to do: once or twice she had peeped into the book her sister was reading, but it had no pictures or conversations in it, `and what is the use of a book,’ thought Alice `without pictures or conversation?’

Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland

Picture books tell a story through a visual medium. Often with text, but sometimes with only images. When we read a picture book, we read those images just as we read the text. Please watch this short history of children’s illustrations.

Watch

You may have seen some images that you recognized in this video. Awards for children’s books include the John Caldecott Medal and the Kate Greenway Medal, named for those illustrators.

As explained in the video above, much of the early history of children’s illustrations was tied to fairy tales. Please look through this slide show of illustrations of famous fairy tale illustrators. Choose two images (from different artists) that stand out to you, and in the comments below, explain which images you chose and why you chose them. What response did they invoke in you?

Choose two images (from different artists) that stand out to you, and in the comments below, explain which images you chose and why you chose them. What response did they invoke in you?

Comments

21 responses to “Thinking about Illustration”

  1. Jennifer Delaguila Avatar
    Jennifer Delaguila

    Two images that I have chosen are Lisbeth Zwerger’s “The Wolf and the Seven Young Kids” and William Steig’s “Shrek”. The reason why I chose Shrek was because I am a big fan of Sherk the movie as well as the sequels. I never knew that it was based on an actual book. And I chose “The Wolf and the Seven Young Kids” because it sounds like an adaptation of Little Red Riding Hood and Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs.

  2. Vanessa Lara Avatar
    Vanessa Lara

    The two images I choose were Little Red Riding Hood by Charles Robinson – I connected with this illustration more than the others shown because I feel like for the version I grew up with and know this picture resembles what Little Red Riding Hood looks like (8 year old, red hood, alone)
    The other image I chose was The Sleeping Beauty by Arthur Rackham – I chose this image because it’s different than what I would’ve seen or grew up seeing. The fairytale makes me think of a princess all dressed up and sleeping peacefully. This illustration shows a more realistic image of anyone seeping.

    1. ashley dai Avatar
      ashley dai

      That’s so interesting to me because I find it to be such an ominous illustration! I agree with you that it is a realistic image of a person sleeping, but realistic in the sense of vulnerability and limpness. To me, Rackham’s “The Sleeping Beauty” oozes predatory vibes, and it is why I found it to be so compelling. It made the essence of the story(from an adult POV) so truthful.

  3. Anifat Abumislimova Avatar
    Anifat Abumislimova

    The first image I chose is “The Little Mermaid” by Anne Anderson. First of all, I chose the little mermaid because this is my favorite cartoon since my childhood. Secondly, this image shows how the mermaid sisters try to save the little mermaid from death by giving her a knife to kill the prince. The second image I chose is “Cinderella” by Arthur Rackham because it shows the prince gently kissing Cinderella’s hand. The other two people in the background seem to be watching, but all the focus is on Cinderella and the prince. This image, for me, shows the fairy tale’s happy ending.

  4. Alexa Mendez Avatar
    Alexa Mendez

    Two images that stood out to me were “the little cap” by Gustave Dore and “the princess and the frog prince” by Edward Brewtnall, these stood out to me the most because they remind me of the little red riding hood and the princess and the frog which are common stories now. I never had seen these versions before but now we can see that these stories go long back.

  5. anthea longville Avatar
    anthea longville

    The first image that stood out to me was “The Fisherman and his wife by Anne Anderson” because of its morals and rich storytelling and the magical fish. The response evoke was greed, dissatisfaction and the consequences of constantly wanting more which is the fisherman wife. The next image was “The Little Match Girl” by Anne Anderson because it brings attention to issues of poverty, homelessness and neglect, comfort and hope as she lights the matches. What it evoke in me was a wide range of emotions, especially empathy, sadness which tugs at my heart string.

  6. Nitzan Naim Avatar
    Nitzan Naim

    1. Beauty and the Beast Kinku Y. Craft – I chose this one because, first of all, it’s beautiful. It perfectly captures how I imagine a fairytale. It looks truly magical! It immediately evoked a sense of mystery and enchantment in me.
    2. Thumbelina by Adrienne Segur – I chose this illustration mostly because I love the vibrant colors and the details. There is so much to look at and explore, and my eyes were drawn to it more than to other illustrations. It really feels like it made the story come to life.

  7. Amy Khait Avatar
    Amy Khait

    Two images that I chose were The Little Mermaid by Anne Anderson and “The Fishermen and his Wife”. I chose the Little Mermaid because it was one of my favorite movies as a kid. Also, I really liked the imagery. I picked The Fishermen and his Wife because I think it has very important lessons about greed and not being grateful for what you have.

  8. Ariana Loyfman Avatar
    Ariana Loyfman

    The “Little Red Riding Hood” image by Arthur Rackham stood out to me because it is a very close representation to how I have always envisioned the story of the Little Red Riding Hood in my imagination. The details of the tall trees compared to the young girl portrays an image of how frightened she must have been to be put into the position that she was in with the wolf while being all alone. The second image that stood out to me was “Cinderella” by Elenore Abbott because firstly I think that the image is very beautiful but also it portrays Cinderella in such a majestic and fairy like way that I have never seen be represented before.

  9. Mahnoor Avatar
    Mahnoor

    1. The image Beauty and the Beast by Edmund Dulac stood out to me because I feel like the beast is depicted as very scary compared to the Disney versions that I’ve seen. It makes him look a lot scarier and makes it harder to have sympathy. 

    2. The image of Cinderella by Wanda Gág also stood out because it was interesting to see how the Step sisters are portrayed as evil and scary over time. 

  10. Tory Sen Avatar
    Tory Sen

    “Goodnight Moon” by Margaret Wise Brown and “The Very Hungry Caterpillar” by Eric Carle are the two pictures that catch my eye.
    The peaceful pictures and repeating story in Goodnight Moon make it a nice bedtime story. It was peaceful and calm because of the way it said goodbye to the outside world. The pictures in The Very Hungry Caterpillar caught my eye right away because of how beautiful they were. Being a worm and then a butterfly changed me into an interest in the growth and change process.

  11. Victoria Lucenti Avatar
    Victoria Lucenti

    “The Little Mermaid” by Anne Anderson and “Hansel and Gretel” by Arthur Rackham both stood out highly to me. Firstly, I chose the “The Little Mermaid”, specifically from the author Anderson because the cover photo had reminded me instantly of images I have seen before from the movie, and I feel as if I have read this book before with my grandma. The cover photo just reminded me so much of images that I have seen from books I have possibly read as a child, as if it was like an instant recap of an old experience from reading the book. I also chose “Hansel and Gretel” by Arthur Rackham because I know I have seen this cover photo as a child, and I am pretty sure I have read this book specifically with my grandma. She was very interested in finding old books that she saved for us to read when I was a child, and this book also brought back an instant recap to memories I had stored away from this time of the start of my reading learning.

  12. Sofia Buttaro Avatar
    Sofia Buttaro

    William Steig’s “Shrek” and Lisbeth Zwerger’s “The Wolf and the Seven Young Kids” are the two pictures I’ve selected. I selected Shrek since it is among my favorite films, along with its follow-ups. To be honest, I had no idea that it was based on a book. Second, I choose “The Wolf and the Seven Young Kids” because it seems like a cross between Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs and Little Red Riding Hood.

  13. Michelle Cortes Rodriguez Avatar
    Michelle Cortes Rodriguez

    1. The Master Cat because it reminds me of Puss in Boots
    2. The Little Mermaid because Im use the seeing it in cartoon version

  14. Selina Chen Avatar
    Selina Chen

    The first image that stood out to me was “Rumpelstiltskin” by Anne Anderson because it seems quite similar to “Rapunzel”. The image included a dwarf coming through the door and that part is a bit different than rapunzel because in rapunzel, it’s a witch coming up the tower. And also in the image the girl is stepping on something bond that looks a bit like her hair but I’m not too sure. Another image that caught my attention was “The Princess and the Frog” by Warwick Goble. In the picture the princess is running away with an apple on her hand which kind of reminded me of snow white.

  15. Naurah Romulus Avatar
    Naurah Romulus

    “The Sleeping Beauty” by Arthur Rackham stood out because it looked so scary. If it weren’t for the text, I would have thought the story was in the horror genre. “Cinderella” by Elenore Abbott also stood out to me because that’s what I chose for my bibliography, and with that research made me find out that it was, initially, a tree that gave Cinderella her wishes, not a fairy godmother.

    1. ashley dai Avatar
      ashley dai

      I totally agree with you Naurah! Rackham really gave it an overwhelming sense of impending horror!

  16. ashley dai Avatar
    ashley dai

    The illustration that struck me most was Arthur Rackham’s “The Sleeping Beauty”. Aside from how evocative it is, I love how closely it resembles printmaking (to me) but is actually an ink & watercolor illustration!

    I also find Edmund Dulac’s work, “The Little Mermaid” to be highly impactful due to its immense sorrowfulness. It makes it make sense why Ariel gives up everything she had. I love Gordon Latte’s depiction of Cinderella because it reads like a sad song written in a major key. It is the only illustration I’ve seen here that uses incredibly bright and vivid colors while displaying hostility and sadness.

    I want to give special praise to Rachel Isadora who, in my opinion, revolutionizes the images we see associated with traditional European fairytales. Not just in her characters, who are unashamedly Black but also in her strong use of bold, colorful patterns with paper-cut collage.

    Also an honorable mention to Shaun Tan’s “Rapunzel” as from an adult POV is incredibly phallic to me and gave me a chuckle.

  17. Kaylee Pontone Avatar
    Kaylee Pontone

    Snow White and Sleeping Beauty both depict young girls asleep with someone approaching them. We are most vulnerable when we’re asleep so without the context of the story these definitely are slightly creepy!

  18. Amna Syeda Avatar
    Amna Syeda

    I chose “Little Red Cap” by Gustave Doré because it reminded me of Old Yeller, a book I read in elementary school. It brought feelings of adventure and danger. I also picked “Bluebeard” by Edmund Dulac because it has a spooky, mysterious feel, which matches the story’s themes of trust and betrayal.

  19. Jaylyn Calles Avatar
    Jaylyn Calles

    Choose two images (from different artists) that stand out to you, and in the comments below, explain which images you chose and why you chose them. What response did they invoke in you?
    ”The sleeping beauty” & ”The three bears” stood out to me. I choose these two imagines because i remember reading these stories as a child. I never seen these version of pictures connected to the story. They make me curious on how they told the story based on the picture.

Leave a Reply to anthea longville Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *